Best ELN for Regulated Labs
Most ELNs we track address 21 CFR Part 11 in some way; for two of them, both open source, there is no published Part 11 evidence. Fewer publish a page describing the controls, fewer still document validation support, and only some back their security statements with a certificate or audit report you can cite. This page follows the criteria of our How we assess page, because published evidence is what a procurement review and an auditor can act on. It is not a judgement on how secure or compliant these products are in use.
Last verified
What matters for this segment
- A dedicated, citable Part 11 page. A page describing electronic signatures, the audit trail and record locking gives a validation team something to reference. A compliance badge on a marketing page does not.
- Security certification you can verify. An ELN holds unpublished research in a vendor's cloud. An ISO 27001 certificate naming its certification body, or a SOC 2 report with a named auditor and period, can go into a supplier assessment; a sentence stating certification cannot.
- Annex 11 for European GMP work. Part 11 is the FDA rule. If your work falls under EU GMP, Annex 11 is the one that applies. Two ELNs we track describe their controls under it: Benchling, in a GxP white paper for its validated tenant, and Uncountable, on its GxP page.
- Validation support from the vendor. IQ/OQ documents, a validation package or a validated environment from the vendor shorten your validation; the PQ and final validation stay with the lab.
Our picks
-
Benchling Benchling Validated Cloud is a dedicated tenant for GxP work. Its page and a GxP white paper describe the controls under Part 11 and Annex 11: signing with username and password, records locked once signed, an audit trail of every action, IQ/OQ documents and an impact assessment with each quarterly release. Schellman issued its ISO/IEC 27001:2022 certificate and audited its SOC 2 Type 2 report. Watch out: Validation documents and controlled releases cover the separate Validated Cloud tenant, while standard tenants are updated daily, and it runs only in Benchling's cloud.
-
SciNote Signing with re-entered credentials, co-signing and an audit trail that cannot be edited and exports to CSV are described in help articles, and the Platinum plan ships IQ/OQ documentation with every release. It can also run on your own servers, as it does in the FDA's labs. Watch out: The Part 11 features come with quoted Premium plans; ISO 27001 and SOC 2 Type II are vendor-stated without a published certificate or auditor.
- Labguru
A dedicated help article describes signing and witnessing, a timestamped audit trail and a new version at each save, and another states that the audit trail cannot be switched off. A validated cloud comes with a validation plan, a report approving each new version and IQ/OQ packages. Watch out: The customer designs and runs its own PQ, Annex 11 and GAMP 5 are not named in the documentation, and pricing is quote-based.
-
Uncountable A GxP page documents Part 11, EU Annex 11 and GAMP 5 Category 4: an automatic audit trail of user, timestamp and before/after values, and e-signatures bound to the user and the record. Uncountable executes and signs IQ/OQ at platform level, with an updated validation kit and GxP impact assessment for each release, and the change log exports with the records it affected. Watch out: ISO 27001 and SOC 2 Type II are vendor-stated, without a published certification body or auditor, and re-authentication at signing is not described publicly. Aimed at formulation R&D, priced on quote, on AWS or in the customer's own cloud.
FAQ
Does any ELN make my lab 21 CFR Part 11 compliant?
No. Part 11 compliance is a property of your validated implementation, your procedures and your records, not of the software. What a vendor can do is provide the technical controls (signatures, audit trails, record locking) and document them well enough that your validation can reference them. That is what this page compares.
Can an ELN be ISO 17025 certified?
No. ISO 17025 accreditation applies to a testing or calibration laboratory, not to software. SciNote cites the standard in a general help article among those it helps customers work under, and says that no software can guarantee compliance.
Which ELN documents EU Annex 11?
Benchling, for its Validated Cloud tenant: its GxP white paper describes the controls it provides under Part 11 and Annex 11, from signatures and audit trails to validation, change control, supplier audits and backups, without mapping them clause by clause. Uncountable names Annex 11 with Part 11 and GAMP 5 on its GxP page, which describes the audit trail, signatures and vendor-executed IQ/OQ. SciNote lists Annex 11 on its regulated-environments page, and Sapio puts it in the title of the assessment sold with its validation package, which is not public. If Annex 11 is decisive, ask each vendor for its assessment before shortlisting.